May 2026 Cheese Club

May

We wanted to do something a little different this month by giving you a bunch of cheeses that we love. Was it my secret way of forcing everyone to help me with selections? Maybe. But it worked, and I personally think everyone picked some really great cheeses.

We hope you love them too.

Stay cheesy,

Jenny, Izaak & the whole crew

May Cheeses

  • A slice of cheese with some red pepper flakes on a wooden cutting board.

    Red Butte Hatch Chili

    All the boxes

    Cow’s milk cheddar with green chili in the paste and red chili on the outside.

    Read more
  • A block of white cheese with a marbled blue-gray pattern on a wooden cutting board.

    Mobay

    All the boxes

    A layer of sheep’s milk and a layer of goat’s milk, divided by ash.

    Read more
  • Close-up of a white, round, textured object on a wooden surface.

    Red Hawk

    All of the boxes

    The funky cheese we all know and love. Most of us anyway.

    Read more
  • Sliced cheese on a wooden cutting board.

    Horseradish Cheddar.

    The Standard, Classic, Deluxe, and The Deluxe

    Is it spicy or is it horseradish?

    Read more
  • Broken pieces of white cheese with a web-like pattern on top, placed on a wooden surface.

    Cremont

    Deluxe Boxes Only

    A beautiful wrinkly rind cheese with buttery texture

    Read more

May Playlist: The Favorites